Have you tried to find a good used one? Here is a used car parts search engine; www.car-parts.com. What is wrong with your old one? I believe this is hard plastic right? If you have a photo of the damage; post it up, might be repairable but obviously, a replacement would be better.
If you can find another good used one; that would be a good way to go or repair what you have. Your other part #, migtht work as well; I know, that on some 2.0L's I have worked on, have a small heather that heats up the pcv (valve), so it doensn't ice up in cold weather conditions? I don't know the differences; I guess, you would have to compare the two, in real life and see, what VW changed, the thicker aspect, could be a possiblity or possibly the heater aspect of the pcv, maybe part of the change?
Connector Pipe. Engine Air Intake Hose.

Part Number: 1C0129684AN
Supersession(s): 1C0-129-684-AN
2.0 LITER. Engine Air Intake Hose.
Fits Beetle Convertible
Convertible, 2.0 LITER, w/cold climate pkg.
If you can find another good used one; that would be a good way to go or repair what you have. Your other part #, migtht work as well; I know, that on some 2.0L's I have worked on, have a small heather that heats up the pcv (valve), so it doensn't ice up in cold weather conditions? I don't know the differences; I guess, you would have to compare the two, in real life and see, what VW changed, the thicker aspect, could be a possiblity or possibly the heater aspect of the pcv, maybe part of the change?
Connector Pipe. Engine Air Intake Hose.

Part Number: 1C0129684AN
Supersession(s): 1C0-129-684-AN
2.0 LITER. Engine Air Intake Hose.
Fits Beetle Convertible
Convertible, 2.0 LITER, w/cold climate pkg.