I just bought this and it does not fit my beetle. The one I need has the arms that are further apart and narrower. This was new from a dealer. I still have the OEM box and wrapping. $125 plus shipping. Willing to trade for the correct door.
They should take it back. If they sold you the wrong one... I think I paid 50 bucks for a used one. So that prices not too bad.
The problem is, when you buy a used one its either broken or its not. Its not like an engine that could be wore out already!
So, nobody really wants to pay that high of a price for a regular old part, even if it is new.