Looking at buying a 2004 beetle convertible. Should I?

18504 Views 28 Replies 10 Participants Last post by bugsy98nb, Sep 24, 2010

abbaleno

Discussion Starter · May 20, 2010

I have been looking for a manual convertible (of any type, not just VW) for a while and finally found the perfect one. It is a 2004 powder blue manual convertible VW bug. It has 55,000 miles on it and seems to be in good shape. My dad was looking to pay $6-7,000 on a new car for me and this one is more expensive, but he is willing to make an exception. We are wanting whatever car I get to last 7-8 more years until I am out of college and to be very low maintenance. I've read that transmission problems are common and it would be expensive to fix. What kind of issues could I expect and do you think this car would last the 7-8 years that I'm wanting it to without having too many problems?
THANKS!

1 - 20 of 29 Posts

Smileybug

· #2 · May 20, 2010

The transmission problems are associated with the automatics. Manual transmissions are pretty reliable. I've got 93k on my car on the original clutch. Only issue I had is there was a plastic piece that broke on my shift linkage, but that is present only on '98 and '99 models as far as I know. Still shifts great! I'd say go for it!

Th only big thing I would make sure of is if the water pump and timing belt has been changed if its around 60k (or past that point). If not, you can do some negotiating on getting the price down.

Evanrude

· #3 · May 20, 2010

abbaleno said:
I have been looking for a manual convertible (of any type, not just VW) for a while and finally found the perfect one. It is a 2004 powder blue manual convertible VW bug. It has 55,000 miles on it and seems to be in good shape. My dad was looking to pay $6-7,000 on a new car for me and this one is more expensive, but he is willing to make an exception. We are wanting whatever car I get to last 7-8 more years until I am out of college and to be very low maintenance. I've read that transmission problems are common and it would be expensive to fix. What kind of issues could I expect and do you think this car would last the 7-8 years that I'm wanting it to without having too many problems?
THANKS!

Hm, from what I have heard, the common transmission problems are with the automatic trans, not the 5 speed manual. 55K miles is good to start with, I got my 2002 in 2007 with only 21K on it!

How much is the 2004 going for? One thing you MUST check, is to see if the timing belt and water pump have been done. They need to be done done 55-60K , if they aren't and the timing belt goes out, it destroys the engine

The timing belt / water pump can be done for under like $500 for all parts and labor. Just, not from VW, they charged over $1200-1400 for that.

So that's something to check. Are there any records of maintenance?

miffmole

· #4 · May 20, 2010

I also have a 5-speed 2004 NBC and it's my favorite car I've ever owned or driven.
Dittos on the timing belt and water pump change. I just did mine at 52k.

I would also make sure that the top mechanism works properly, and that the wings close all the way down when the top is down. That's the only problem I've had, and I still have it.

Here's my car:
http://newbeetle.org/forums/photos-...s-silver-04-nb-convertible-gls-1-8-turbo.html

Evanrude

· #5 · May 20, 2010

miffmole said:
I also have a 5-speed 2004 NBC and it's my favorite car I've ever owned or driven.
Dittos on the timing belt and water pump change. I just did mine at 52k.

I would also make sure that the top mechanism works properly, and that the wings close all the way down when the top is down. That's the only problem I've had, and I still have it.

Here's my car:
http://newbeetle.org/forums/photos-...s-silver-04-nb-convertible-gls-1-8-turbo.html

I had mine done at 52.5k, and got great kit from ECS Tuning that included everything I needed including new G12 cooling flood.

miffmole

· #6 · May 20, 2010

Evanrude said:
I had mine done at 52.5k, and got great kit from ECS Tuning that included everything I needed including new G12 cooling flood.

Same here, but I already had the G12, so I bought the $219 kit. I was remembering what you said about being able to put your finger through your plastice OEM impeller whan mine was taken off. Mine was solid as a rock, though. I'm still glad it's gone, though.

miffmole

· #7 · May 20, 2010 (Edited)

miffmole said:
I would also make sure that the top mechanism works properly, and that the wings close all the way down when the top is down. That's the only problem I've had, and I still have it.

Here are the infamous wings that come on the 2003-04 models (see photo below). If the wings on the car you're looking at look like this when your top is down, I wouldn't buy it, unless it was repaired to my satisfaction.
I've had mine in for a fix 4-5 times and still have this problem. Now, I'm past my warranty and have to live with it.

scarabY2k

· #8 · May 20, 2010

Smileybug said:
The transmission problems are associated with the automatics. Manual transmissions are pretty reliable. I've got 93k on my car on the original clutch. Only issue I had is there was a plastic piece that broke on my shift linkage, but that is present only on '98 and '99 models as far as I know. Still shifts great! I'd say go for it!

Th only big thing I would make sure of is if the water pump and timing belt has been changed if its around 60k (or past that point). If not, you can do some negotiating on getting the price down.

What she said

And I echo the sentiments of the others concerning the timing belt. See if it's been done or if they can do it for you. Other than that you should be golden, especially with a manual trans.

Please keep up posted on your beetlequest... I'm hoping you get it

uwharrie

· #9 · May 21, 2010

I have an 04 vert with 62K miles. Has the auto tranny and 1.8T. We just had the timing belt/ WP done for $750 (at the dealership no less)
So far the only issues I have had is with the darn electric windows on the drivers side. first it was the latch ( window was not dropping when door opened) cost $300, then it was the regulators in both the front and rear windows cost $650. Also continue to have issues with the rear liner not staying in despite new clips being installed.
Also had to have the bushing (I think that is what it was) replaced in the front suspension.
I LOVE my car but it has not been cheap to maintain.
My husband told the dealer he did not want to come back because it cost $1500 every time it was in the shop.
this last time it was Timing belt/WP, 2 widow reg. & replace transmission fluid (which they really did not recommend curious enough)

BTW the dealer has not been much more than what we have been quoted by an indie shop. we chose the dealer due to warrantee and the fact they will give us a loaner.

See less See more

Tinderstick

· #10 · May 22, 2010

I was in similar situation

Interestingly I was in similar situation as you and I faced the same choice. Unfortunately I did not ask the right questions on time. However I still love my choice and I love my "new" used beetle from 2004. It is really nice and well done car. Engine is good really pleasure to drive. The only problem I have is with the flaps that the people already mentioned to you. Mine wont go down all the way so it is creating lot of trouble. I am from Europe and I bought this car relatively cheap for European market so I don't mind paying some extra money to replace it. The guy from the dealer also promised to settle the costs trough some additional insurance I acquired.

Thus the only advice I can give you which is Beetle specific, and I learned it hard way, take care of those flaps. If they are not working properly there seem to be couple of solutions : they can be removed, the roof can be made manual (for 190$ in US as I could read), or they can be replaced (apparently up to 600-1000$ for full replacement in US). So if they are not working it is not end of the world, but if I would be you (or if I knew about this problem before) I would just bargain down for the price of their replacement.

Other than that beetle seems to bee really reliable and enjoyable car.

See less See more

sb_beetle

· #11 · May 22, 2010

miffmole said:
Here are the infamous wings that come on the 2003-04 models (see photo below). If the wings on the car you're looking at look like this when your top is down, I wouldn't buy it, unless it is repaired to my satisfaction.
I've had mine in for a fix 4-5 times and still have this problem. Now, I'm past my warranty and have to live with it.

Have you tried messing with the microswitch located in the windshield frame above the passenger's side?

miffmole

· #12 · May 22, 2010 (Edited)

sb_beetle said:
Have you tried messing with the microswitch located in the windshield frame above the passenger's side?

You mean in here, right (see photo below)?

I did look in there and see a small silver plate, or something. It didn't seem to have any play in it or anything, but I did spray some WD40 down in there.

It hasn't seemed to make any difference, though.

sb_beetle

· #13 · May 22, 2010

Yes!!!

miffmole said:
You mean in here, right (see photo below)?

I did look in there and see a small silver plate, or something. It didn't seem to have any play in it or anything, but I did spray some WD40 down in there.

It hasn't seemed to make any difference, though.

You need to reach your pinky finger under it an lift it. It should have play as that is the switch for the flaps. It might take a few lifts but it is definitely the switch.

miffmole

· #14 · May 22, 2010

I tried, but couldn't get my pinky to go down that far...its' too fat, I guess. I used a steak knife tip instead, but couldn't get any movement.
Maybe now that the WD40 has been on a day, it will have loosened up. I'll go out and see.

sb_beetle

· #15 · May 22, 2010

miffmole said:
I tried, but couldn't get my pinky to go down that far...its' too fat, I guess. I used a steak knife tip instead, but couldn't get any movement.
Maybe now that the WD40 has been on a day, it will have loosened up. I'll go out and see.

I'm 100% positive it should move. Might try a piece of a bent coat hangar or something. The switch should move upward about 1/4 inch.

miffmole

· #16 · May 22, 2010 (Edited)

It moved!

Well, this time I could reach the switch with my finger, and it did move...however, I'm still getting the same result.
It's going down about this far on the first go, even though I'm still pulling up on my button. Then, it freezes, and won't go up or down.

sb_beetle

· #17 · May 22, 2010

miffmole said:
Well, this time I could reach the switch with my finger, and it did move...however, I'm still getting the same result.
It's going down about this far on the first go, even though I'm still pulling up on my button. Then, it freezes, and won't go up or down.

Did you try resetting your windows via the all window switch? I know it sounds wierd, but the systems are linked. I had a glitch a few weeks back where the top/flaps wouldn't move at all. Cycled the windows and... all be @#$! Is that more movement than before?

miffmole

· #18 · May 22, 2010 (Edited)

I've seen differing methods of resetting on here. Is it Up>Down>Up, or Down>Up>Down?
No, so far the movement is about the same.

sb_beetle

· #19 · May 22, 2010

Hahaha

miffmole said:
I've seen differing methods of resetting on here. Is it Up>Down>Up, or Down>Up>Down?
No, so far the movement is about the same.

I don't ever think i've paid attention, but my top and windows were all the way down so I'm going to say up-down-up

miffmole

· #20 · May 24, 2010 (Edited)

sb_beetle said:
I don't ever think i've paid attention, but my top and windows were all the way down so I'm going to say up-down-up

Well, after doing a reset as you suggested, it went all the way down twice in a row...something it hasn't done lately! Is it fixed? I guess I'll find out in the next day or two.
A storm's on the way, so I didn't press my luck after that, LOL.
Thanks for your help and suggestions.

1 - 20 of 29 Posts

This is an older thread, you may not receive a response, and could be reviving an old thread. Please consider creating a new thread.