Here are the dingy headlights I was talking about. It's so bad that we drove it with the high beams on (we had a low beam out) and no one could even notice cause they were so dull. No one flashed their lights at us, we actually couldn't see very much at all with either low or high beams. I'm prepared to sink $300 ish on new headlights if it comes down to it but I'm hoping I can just restore these and go with a brighter H1 bulb.