VW Beetle Forum banner
61 - 80 of 83 Posts
The battery to fuse box cable I put on from NAPA must be defective! Today I had the Bug idling and when I moved the cable it caused the engine speed to change. I tested it by wiggling and holding fuse box still and the engine speed varied in time with the cable movements. I ordered a new cable from innovative wiring! I will let you know how that works.....
 
I got the new cable yesterday and today I installed it.Battery is charging normally and the engine speed no longer varies when I wiggle the cable. I am going to drive it to work for a few days and see how it goes.
 
Another update! Everything is working fine still! The North Dakota snow is keeping my Bug indoors, but as soon as possible it will be out getting fresh air again!! I have put lots of miles on the Bug since the fix described in this thread! Thank you so much for taking the time to read and post!
 
Cool, glad you got it fixed and it stayed fixed! :) In retrospect, can you tell us all the repairs done, what the causes of the problems you had were and what is your assessment of the of the quality of the innovative wiring cable you purchased? This kind of information, should help the next person having similar problems; especially, those of us who are going to need to do a full repair of this wiring problem in the future. I'm still debating in buying raw cable and the necessary crumping tools, to diy.Thanks.
 
Initially I was having issues with the battery charging, so that led me to replace battery then the alternator. Then the fuse box melted so it got replaced, and at that time I upgraded the power cable for it with a cable, which was not a perfect fit but I made it work, from NAPA. When I still had issues I went with the wiring harness for the alternator, then I still had problems so I put new and much heavier duty battery cables on the Bug. After having replaced everything in the charging system I still had charging issues. So after more reading and advice on here I was at a loss for why it was happening. One day I decided to do more checking and could not find anything wrong, but I did notice the idle changed as I wiggled cables looking for a loose connection. The power cable for the fuse box was tight but the engine speed varied as I moved the cable. I decided to try the Innovative Wiring cable and since installing it I have had zero problems with my charging system.

I definitely would buy the Innovative Wiring cable. It is a perfect fit, shipped quickly and I had it in no time it seemed.

I replaced the alternator, battery, alternator wiring harness, both battery cables, fuse box, and power cable for fuse box twice.

In retrospect I should have went with the new fusebox and Innovative attire Wiring cable first, and I would have probably been done. Being that as it is, I am glad I changed out everything else so I know it is all brand new and will go for as long as I am able to drive my Bug!
 
Thanks, for the repair review, parts list, problem analysis and feedback! Good work and good to hear; you are all fixed up and back on the road! :)
 
The fusebox on my 1.8L T new beetle recently melted and warranted a further look. This issue appears to be pretty common among this and other similar VW's so I've decided to share my findings and what I feel will be a long term solution.

I agree, the problem is excessive heat at the connection interface between the wire terminals and the fuse, not excessive current in the wire (remember the fuse didn't blow and the entire wire isn’t melted). I believe that the root of the problem is that the connection on the non-battery side of the high current (i.e. alternator and interior) fuse loosens slightly over time. This creates increased resistance, which tends to soften the black plastic housing base, reducing clamping pressure which causes even less contact, more resistance and more heat until everything spirals out of control. Poor design from the get go.

The battery side of each of the fuses tightens up with nuts that are all metal-to-metal clamping everything together and remain tight over time. This side never gets hot and never has a problem. The non-battery side of the fuses (towards the rear of the car) is different because they are all individual. Each individual bolt comes up from the bottom, and comes thru holes on the black plastic housing. There is a thin drawn sheet metal washer that is supposed to support the clamp load of the tightened nut. The problem is that this sheet metal washer is totally inadequate to support the clamp load and crushes easily under the clamp load of a tightened nut. (Clamp loads on a tightened M6 nut can be hundreds of pounds) A better design would have been to use a metal screw with a shoulder washer with some thickness that wouldn’t deform under load. I’ve looked at several different manufactures fuse blocks including Genuine VW parts and they all share the same poor design.

Here is what I did to solve the problem. Get a new fuse block. Remove the bottom black plastic flap to expose the back of all of the hex screw heads. You’ll need a small screwdriver to open all the snaps. All of the 10 M6 bolts will need to be increased in length on both sides of the fuse. I left the thin drawn sheet metal washers in place, but added an additional nut on the topside of the plastic so that the fuse now bottoms on the new nuts above the black plastic rather then crushing the drawn sheet metal washers. I used some Loctite on this nut and let it dry before final assembly. You’ll need to add a nut to both sides of the fuse to lift up both sides so that the fuse stays horizontal and isn’t cocked at an angle. The basic idea is that when the nuts are tightened up the top outside nuts clamp the fuses to the wire crimp terminals and then bottom on a new Loctited nuts instead of the flimsy sheet metal washers. All stresses remain in the metal, bolts/nuts/fuses and terminal ends and there’s no load clamping the sheet metal washer or the black plastic base. The nuts will stay tight, Consider adding a split washer in the stack-up to retain clamp pressure.

Pay attention to get the correct size fuses back onto to the correct wires! Different years and models use different fuse values.

Remember when you put the bolts back in they need to be rotationally aligned to fit into their black plastic hex receptacle in order be able to shut everything back together. Pay attention to this otherwise you will go thru multiple assembly cycles like me.

There’s no need to over tighten the nuts. They wont come loose over time. Overtorquing will just spin the hex head in the hex of the plastic base and ruin it making the base hard to close.

To verify everything’s working well once you start the car back up and the alternator is charging the battery with max current, the top of the rear bolt on the fuse block should remain pretty cool to the touch. If it’s too warm there will be a voltage drop between to B+ side of the fuse (front of car) and the eyelet terminal of the alternator wire. Even a .1-volt drop at this junction with 80 amps of charging current will generate 8 watts of heat in a very tiny area. The lower the voltage drops, the cooler and better! Check it over time until you are sure everything is steady state.

As for the three 30 amp flat bade fuses, I’ve also had the same problem with intermittent AC fans and or ABS brakes due too poor electrical contact. My diagnosis is similar. Its not excess current but poor connections caused but cheap terminals that cant support the current loads.
To solve the problem at one point, I out boarded a 30 amp Air Con fan fuse (got my solder iron out), which worked but wasn’t pretty. In my most recent iteration with a new start over fuse block I noted that the sheet metal fingers which contact the 3 fuses were rotated 90 degrees giving substantially better metal contact area with the fuse terminals and so I added silicone grease to the fuse blades and kept the aftermarket manufactures rotated design. If you have the original design (contacts all in the same plane) I suppose I would outboard all three fuses. Not pretty and a lot of soldering work. Make sure you use fuse holders (Amazon has 30 amp fuse holders) which can support the 30 amps…….Volkswagen didn’t. If they did ,we wouldn’t have the problem and there wouldn’t have been class action lawsuits.

(I don’t think you can determine which design you have unless you take it apart)

Good luck, hope my pictures help

Cheap sheet metal stamped washer, which is sandwich thru the black plastic base.
This is the root of the problem because it gets crushed.

Image


This is basically my fix to add nuts to the top of the sheet metal part. Note Loctite.

Nuts were also added to the battery (front) side to allow the fuses to remain horizontal.

All bolts were exchanged for longer pieces to allow for the extra nuts.
Image


Image


Image


The bolt hex heads need to be rotationally aligned to fit back in their respective plastic recess’ allowing re-snapping everything back together.

Image


30 Amp Fuses

My original fuse block I had to outboard the AC fan fuse because of poor contact. Note the orientation of the tangs contacting the fuse blades are all in the same flat plane. It’s a Poor design with minimal metal contact to the fuse blades, hence the need to outboard the fuse.

Image


Once I had the alternator fuse over-heating issues, I decided to start over with a new fuse block (modified as shown above), which happened to have improved 30 amp discrete fuse holder contacts. This design looked much better with more surface area of metal contact so I decided to keep it with no modifications, except to add silicone grease, however I do periodically do the same voltage drop test I did above. Remember voltage drops generate heat, causing melt down.

Image
I've also had problems having to change 'Fuse Blocks' on 'New Beetles and Gti Polo's' they are losing connection and the metal fuses deteriorate. Accounts for endless problems in VW's the old reputation of VW (If only everything in the world was as reliable as a Volkswagen' does not seem to work these days?
 
I am having the same issue with my Jetta TDI. I read this forum and I felt compelled to chime in. I replaced the fuse box last year because the A/C coolant fans were not turning on and when I looked at the fuse box, lots of the fuses were charred and melted. None of the fuses were blown. Additionally, large parts of the fuse enclosure was melted too. After replacing the fuse box, everything seemed to be working fine.

Then, 2 months ago, the car's AC started to have intermittent problems, eventually the AC stopped working completely. I pulled fuse S180 and sure enough, the plastic in the fuse was melted but the fuse was not blown.

I am an electrical engineer. And seeing melted plastic without blown fuses is an important clue to what is going wrong. jfoj is mostly correct in his diagnosis, although his bedside manner leaves a lot to be desired.

The culprit is too much heat. If there is enough heat to melt fuse plastic and housing plastic, then that is a lot of heat. If the insulation of the wire is not melting, this is proof that the internals of the cable are not getting hot enough to melt that particular plastic. If replacing a cable, seems to have solved the problem, this is more likely due to the fact that replacing the cable also resulted in replacing the connector at the end of the cable. Most heat in a situation like this is produced at connection points. Lots of things can be causing the system to overheat. Also, each component in the system adds to the heat, the wires, the connectors, the fuses. If they were all poorly designed, or they all corroded over time together, then replacing one cable might be enough to drop the generated heat enough to stop the melting. Additionally, as the plastic slowly melts, the contacts shift around, the shifting can cause additional shorts or increases in resistance which will cause even more melting. So, you can replace the fuse box and think you have solved the problem, only for it to pop up again years later.

Potential Causes for too much heat:
1. Fuse box uses plastic that melts too easily. (Unlikely, due to the fact that it is getting hot enough to melt my fuse plastic)
2. Too many fuses in fuse box. (Maybe)
3. Fuse box located in an improper, especially hot place in the engine compartment. (Maybe, especially if the battery gets really hot on these VWs for some reason)
4. Improperly secured wire mounting points which allow the wire connections to flex, which leads to corrosions and breakage of individual strands of wires, causing increased resistance and thus more heat. (Very likely, evidenced by the fact that a lot of people report replacing the wire from the alternator to the fuse box fixes the problem, and because the wire gets flexed every time someone messes with the battery cover) (Unlikely that this is the sole problem, considering my S180 fuse melted without anything else in the fuse box melting)
5. Poorly designed fuse mounts (Likely). The fact that my S180 fuse melted while nothing else did (the second time around) indicates that there is heat concentrated on only that part of the fuse box, this would not happen if the sole source of heat was the wire from the alternator to the fuse box.
6. Damaged coolant fans causing too much current draw and heat (less likely). If the VW engineers sized the fuses properly, the fuses should blow longer before any plastic melts. BUT... it is possible that the VW engineers sized the fuse knowing that the coolant fan would start to draw more current over time as the car aged. And, they may have wanted the coolant fans to continue to function even at higher current draws (maybe because the condenser coils have gotten clogged and blocked airflow). But, maybe they messed up and didn't calculate how much extra heat would be produced by the increased current draw (I doubt they did this as that would be pretty dumb) and that little amount of extra heat also contributed to all of the other little heat producing things going on and it was enough to increase the total temperature by enough degrees for plastic to start melting.
7. Battery producing too much heat. Maybe a cheap battery was installed that is producing too much heat. Maybe the overall current draw of system is up for lots of reasons, all causing the battery to produce more heat than the VW engineers initially expected. (Fairly likely)
8. The entire engine compartment is heating up too much, increasing the base line heat the fuse box is subjected too. (Fairly likely)

My main point:
The heat that is melting the plastic is coming from multiple locations. It is highly likely that there are multiple causes. And, heat generated at one point, through convection and conduction makes it way to other parts of the fuse box, albeit at lower levels. The VW engineers should have taken all of the heat sources into account when designing the fuse box, but they obviously did not. Here is some math to illustrate my point...

I am making up these numbers to make a point, so don't try to read into them too much.
Let's pretend the plastic melts at 300 dF

Brand new VW fuse box heat sources:
Heat from Combustion: 100W
Heat from Battery: 20W
Heat from Fuse Connectors: 5W
Heat from Wire Crimped Ends: 5W
Heat from Wires: 1W
Total: 131W
Let's pretend that in a state of equilibrium these heat inputs cause the plastic's temperature to max out at 200dF

10 year old VW fuse box heat sources:
Heat from Combustion: 120W (+20W)
Heat from Battery: 40W (+20W)
Heat from Fuse Connectors: 20W (+15W)
Heat from Wire Crimped Ends: 20W (+15W)
Heat from Wires: 1.5W (+0.5W)
Total: 201.5W (+70.5W)
Let's pretend that going over 200W enabled the temp of the plastic to exceed 300dF.

So, which component would be at fault? And which components could you fix to stop the problem? Pretty much all of them are at fault, and fixing any one component would fix the problem (at least temporarily, but possibly permanently).

Today, I am going to go out and use my voltmeter to check for the voltage drops across all of my connectors. In the electrical world, when there is increased heat a specific spot, it is almost always due to poor connections. Those poor connections can be identified by their voltage drop. There should be almost no voltage drop in a good connection. In the the 12V to 14V world of cars, I would be concerned with any voltage drops over 10mV, and anything over 500mV is going to produce a ton of heat and needs to be fixed. If I saw anything with a voltage drop of 100mV, I would assume a poor connection. I haven't gone out to probe my car yet, but I expect the connections inside the fuse box to be the main culprit (both the crimped end of wires and the fuse connection spots). I will report back what I find. In an ideal world, there would be NO voltage drop across anything in the fuse box, but, we do not live in an ideal world.
 
Just went out and probed the fuse box, did a more thorough visual inspection and I looked at my fuse box from last year that I had saved. All signs point to a singular cause. The crimped end of the wire running from fuse S177 to the alternator. 99.99% sure corrosion in the last 1 or 2 inches of that wire is increasing the resistance and the heat. Why?

1. Visually, both the current fuse box and the old fuse box had melting around that end of fuse S177 only.
2. Unlike all of the other wire in the fuse box. The alternator end of S177 was super super hot, I could only touch it for maybe 1 or 2 seconds before it was too hot. And! The car had only been running maybe 5 minutes. The opposite side of fuse S177 was not hot. The last 2 to 3 inches of the wire from the alternator was also very hot and there were signs of damaged insulation on that part of the wire.
3. The voltage drop across the fuse was 30mV. All of the other large fuses had a voltage drop of 10mV.
4. I do not agree with previous posters who claim the bolts/nuts/washers holding down the fuses are too blame. I broke apart my old fuse box and the construction seems fine, there is metal embedded in the plastic part of the fuse box that maybe the previous posters missed that is allowing for a secure enough connection. I would recommend some locktite or a lock washer to keep the bolts from loosening though.
5. It is common for wire to corrode on their ends, this is not a surprising turn of events, especially when the wire must be flexed everytime the battery is replaced.

The wire doesn't seem long enough to cut and recrimp while still maintaining enough length to reattach it to the fuse's post. Also, this would be a temporary fix... something would need to be done to inhibit future corrosion. Dielectric grease applied around the crimped end of the wire after the connection has been tightened.

I'm not sure what jfoj's full opinion on dielectric grease is, but... it is fine to use in these situations. See this article for a full explanation. Dielectric grease is a great way to prevent corrosion at the end of wires.
 
One more comment.

So, why is the A/C coolant fan fuse melting?

I think it is too much of a coincidence to think their is another issue going on that is causing that fuse to melt. Instead, I think what is happening is that the alternator fuse (S177) is producing soo much heat, heat that has nowhere to go inside the enclosure. And the A/C coolant fan fuse is already sort of hot from running the coolant fan, combine that with the fact that the A/C coolant fan fuse (S180) is the first small fuse the heat from S177 encounters, so S180 is getting the bulk of the conducted heat from S177. Adding S177's conducted heat to the heat already being produced by high amount of current needed for the coolant fans, and it is melting.

Part of me wondered why S176, S164, S163, and S162 are not melting, but I think it is just because they have a tougher construction.
 
Based upon your engineering background; what are you thoughts, on the SMP and MotorKing improved fuse boxes? They do seem, to have improvements; to the stock design. It would be interesting; if you acquired some of these, did some testing and gave your opionion of them.
 
 
I looked at this product...

I still don't have the link to the MotorKing product, so I won't comment on that.

My overall impression, the Techsmart page is full of marketing hype and I am not sure I would trust it. They kept referring to the "Competition" product, without actually stating who they were comparing too. I am sure there are some cheap knockoff 3rd party part vendors who skimp by with inexpensive components, but I highly doubt that would be the case with OEM parts. The fact that the website only claims to be better than 'competitor' and not specifically better than OEM parts, makes me be suspicious about whether or not their parts are better. Visually speaking, the TechSmart fuse box looks almost identical to my OEM fusebox, although the smaller fuses in the OEM fuse box looked to be of higher quality.

VW almost certainly didn't undersize their wire gauge, the quality of their wire connectors, or ship with shoddy fuses.

Also, replacing the fuse box and the wire running from it to the positive terminal of the battery, is not most people's major issue. For most people, they need to replace the wire running from the fuse box to the alternator (or, at a minimum cut the end off of it and recrimp with a new connector). But, replacing the fuse box, should fix the problem temporarily (until it melts again in the future).

Now, will a higher quality fuse box be able to handle the heat put off by the failing connector on the wire from the alternator? Maybe... but, I don't think that will be the case for the techsmart fuse box, it looks like it is pretty close to the same construction as the OEM fuse box.
 
MotorKing/AutoTech USA: (marketing and improved design specifics):

1998-2003 VW’s have a problem with the fuse box, the 30 amp fuse terminal burns or melts, sometimes on the fusible link area. This is caused by an insufficient design fuse terminal contact point, which is too small and may become loose with the bad connection. Another common problem is that it may cause intermittent circuit malfunction, which in turn the fuse terminal overheats and melts the fuse box housing. Our new improved design fuse box 1) Upgrades the 30 amp fuse terminals at each contact point from 1mm to 5mm full contact. 2) Upgrades the melting point to 285 to 300 degrees. *The original part’s melting point is only able to tolerate 150-185 degrees, we have upgraded our replacement part with heavy duty plastic that is able to tolerate 285-300 degrees to insure that it is the most durable and best quality on the market.



The quality of aftermarket "improved" parts; are always a open question, I guess one would have to try one, to know for sure. The upgraded contact points for the fuses and increased heat resistant plastic makes some sense; although, addressing the primary causes of problems, rather then just replacing damaged parts that are symptoms of a greater issue, probably won't fix many issues people are dealing with. Obviously, people that keep replacing their fuse boxes with the same problem; again, again, are not addressing the primary issue, causing the symptomatic problem.
 
61 - 80 of 83 Posts